Product Idea

Expand all | Collapse all

Feature Request: Review - Comments Interatction

  • 1.  Feature Request: Review - Comments Interatction

    Posted 09-06-2019 14:34
    Note: As requested by the community, the feature requests from the original discussion titled "Feature Requests: Review Related" are now split into an individual discussion per feature that was originally listed.

    Feature Request: Within the Review, can there be a more interactive feature that allows reviewers to address questions/issues to other reviewers/Jama users?
    • Reason: Questions that the reviewers are asking to other reviewers/employees are not being transmitted to other reviewers/employees readily. The current Review comment setup just watermarks the feedback as a question type (if used at all).  For reviewers/employees who have bypassed/never seen the requirement prior to when the inquiry is made, will not see the inquiry.  The notification setting only notifies activities on the requirements that the reviewer/moderator has commented/edited on.   


    ------------------------------
    Yvonne Stephens
    Systems Engineer
    Firefly Aerospace
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Feature Request: Review - Comments Interatction

    Posted 09-07-2019 07:38
    This is once of our top requests to be able to assign review comments to and individual

    ------------------------------
    Elizabeth Rosenberg
    Alight Solutions
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Feature Request: Review - Comments Interatction

    Posted 09-08-2019 10:08
    + 1

    We can certainly benefit from this too.

    ------------------------------
    Robena Sukhu
    Sun Life Financial
    ON
    416-496-5456
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Feature Request: Review - Comments Interatction

    Posted 09-09-2019 08:02
    It would be great to have the ability to assign review comments.
    In addition maybe even decide which review comments are transferred to the item after the review closes.

    ------------------------------
    Sven Schmidberger
    Irdeto
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Feature Request: Review - Comments Interatction

    Posted 17 days ago
    Hi,
    I support both Ideas:
    - assign review comments
    - decide which review comments are transferred to the item after the review closes.
         See similar request: Review comment tracking outside of review https://community.jamasoftware.com/communities/community-home/digestviewer/viewthread?MessageKey=27f9181b-526d-40dc-9656-e5cc91e8fd9f&CommunityKey=4eac21f6-24d1-4f1e-92bd-76860b52af2c&tab=digestviewer#bm27f9181b-526d-40dc-9656-e5cc91e8fd9f


    ------------------------------
    Christian Binard
    ON semiconductor
    Belgium
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: Feature Request: Review - Comments Interatction

    Posted 17 days ago
    I think that we should also give the possibility to the moderator to assign request of others (delegate) and to change the type of the request.
    Often I see that commenters are not using the comment type feature (Question/Propose change/This is an issue). For example they don't indicate that their comment is a question and so it is difficult to trace if it got an answer.

    ------------------------------
    Christian Binard
    ON semiconductor
    Belgium
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: Feature Request: Review - Comments Interatction

    Posted 17 days ago
    +1
    We asked for similar request to be able to assign review comments to user.

    ------------------------------
    Elizabeth Rosenberg
    Alight Solutions
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Feature Request: Review - Comments Interatction

    Posted 17 days ago
    The way around is also interesting: as a reviewer, when I come back to the review, I'd like to filter for Items that got new comments since my last activity (approval / comment). Email notifications are not handy if you want to treat all changes at once.

    This is even  more important if I'm the moderator: I regularly check the state of the review and don't want to read again old comments. To enable this maybe a new type of marker (other than approval / comment) should be added.

    In case I did approved but somebody made a further comment, it would be good that my green check-mark gets yellow to get a visual warning that I may revisit my approval.

    ------------------------------
    Christian Binard
    ON semiconductor
    Belgium
    ------------------------------