Regarding comment in Review Center

Options
Koji Okumura
Koji Okumura Member Posts: 3
in
I want to see comments in the Review Center from items in the project.
Because sometimes some important discussions occur in the Review Center. But after reviewing, we can't see there discussion from item's comment area. If we can see the discussion of Review Center from item. It's very helpful for user.

Comments

  • [Deleted User]
    [Deleted User] Product Manager Posts: 35
    Options
    Thanks for sharing the idea! We've recently heard this need quite a lot, so it's on our roadmap but not yet scoped or given a timeframe. 

    Question for you: If we put Review Center comments on an item, would you expect to be able to reply to that comment (and alert that comment's author) to continue the conversation?

    Our current thought is that we would add Review Center comments as essentially "read only" so they're a record on the item, but it's a "closed" comment/conversation. It felt odd to have a conversation around a Review Center comment, since reviews might have different participants and context - do you agree?
  • GrantMore
    GrantMore Member, Functional Safety Kit (FSK) Posts: 32
    edited October 2017
    Options
    This is one we've been keen to see sorted out for a while.

    We'd like to see fundamental harmonization of the Review Center and Stream functionality. 

    The way we see it is that Stream is always open for comments and discussion, but reviews have a finite timeline for commenting. That said, it would be very useful to have any context provided by Stream discussions available in Review Center (i.e. "Access Stream comments for this item" button in Review Center) and likewise Review Center comments all mirrored into the Stream on the Project side of the tool, and critically available for unsolicited comments/feedback at any future point (as any Stream comment would be).

    I agree with Okumura-san in that it would be very useful to have a function to see "all related comments" for a particular item in the project side of the tool. The use case is I have an item and I want to see what's been discussed about it since it was created (i.e. all comments, including those from all reviews). Most likely in order of latest feedback first. Was this item reviewed? What was the feedback? How about a tab with "all feedback"?

    /G

    ------------------------------
    Grant More
    Head of Systems Engineering
    Analog Devices
    ------------------------------
    -------------------------------------------
    Original Message:
    Sent: 10-17-2017 19:16
    From: Robin Calhoun
    Subject: Regarding comment in Review Center

    Thanks for sharing the idea! We've recently heard this need quite a lot, so it's on our roadmap but not yet scoped or given a timeframe.

    Question for you: If we put Review Center comments on an item, would you expect to be able to reply to that comment (and alert that comment's author) to continue the conversation?

    Our current thought is that we would add Review Center comments as essentially "read only" so they're a record on the item, but it's a "closed" comment/conversation. It felt odd to have a conversation around a Review Center comment, since reviews might have different participants and context - do you agree?

    ------------------------------
    Robin Calhoun
    Product Manager
    Jama Software
    ------------------------------

    Original Message:
    Sent: 10-17-2017 18:48
    From: Koji Okumura
    Subject: Regarding comment in Review Center

    I want to see comments in the Review Center from items in the project.
    Because sometimes some important discussions occur in the Review Center. But after reviewing, we can't see there discussion from item's comment area. If we can see the discussion of Review Center from item. It's very helpful for user.

    ------------------------------
    Koji Okumura
    ------------------------------
    Grant More
    Systems Engineering Specialist
    More Consulting Ltd.
  • Koji Okumura
    Koji Okumura Member Posts: 3
    Options
    In my opinion, Jama have to have same or similar interface between Review Center and Item comment are.
    If the comment of Review Center is !question, the comment in the item should be same !question.
    This is ideal situation for me.
    Thanks,
    Koji
  • [Deleted User]
    [Deleted User] Posts: 14
    edited June 2018
    Options
    I wanted to bump this. I am not sure if there is another open Feature Request for the topic, but this feature seems to be critical to one of the main purposes of a requirements management tool, which is so track the entire history of a requirement. 
    More comments are made on an item during reviews than outside of them. Items go through many changes and knowing exactly why is hugely important.
    Getting these comments moved over to the project in any form (read only or other) is helpful. 

    Thanks,
    Nick

Categories